Page 7 - Read Online

Lu et al. J Mater Inf 2022;2:11 I http://dx.doi.org/10.20517/jmi.2022.15 Page 3 of 18

Table 1. Performance accuracy (%) with patch images
Type of data Reference Method Quoted mode a
Ni-Mo binary system
Phase equilibria 70-85 at.% Ni Grube et al. [7] ×
60-76 at.% Ni Bloom et al. [8] •
fcc Guthrie et al. [9] ◦
Overall Casselton et al. [10] TA, OM, XRD ◦
bcc liquidus Wicker et al. [11] CA, DTA •
Below 1600 K Heijwegen et al. [12] DC, EPMA •
fcc Gust et al. [13] (Not available) •
bcc solidus Kang et al. [14] EPS, EPMA •
fcc + Ni4Mo Kobayashi et al. [15] XRD •
bcc solidus, fcc + Yaqoob et al. [3] EA, EPMA •
1173K and 1073K Zhu et al. [16] DM, EPMA •
1373K and 1123K Shi et al. [17] DC, EA, SEM, XRD •
Thermodynamic properties Enthalpy of mixing of liquid Chistyakov et al. [18] Calorimetry •
Sudavtsova [19] Calorimetry ×
Enthalpy of formation for ,
Spencer et al. [20] AC •
heat capacity for
Enthalpies of formation for Kubaschewski et al. [21] AC •
Heat capacity of Ni 4Mo Norem [22] AC •
Brook et al. [23] AC ×
Basak [24] AC •
Activity Katayama et al. [25] EMF ×
Meshkov et al. [26] EMF •
Tsai et al. [27] EMF •
Pejryd [28,29] EMF ×
Koyama et al. [30] EMF •
Sudavtsova [19] EMF ×
Curie temperature Khan et al. [34] VSM, SQUID •
Magnetic moment Ghosh et al. [35] VSM, SQUID •
Mo-Re system
Phase equilibria Overall Dickinson et al. [36] OM, XRD •
Knapton et al. [37] OM, XRD •
Savitskii et al. [38,39] OM, XRD •
1473K and 1873K,
Thermodynamic properties Farzadfar et al. [40] OM, XRD, DRC •
enthalpy of formation
Ni-Mo-Re system
Phase equilibria 1425K Kodentsov et al. [41] DC ×
Borisov et al. [42]
1425K DC & EA •
Slyusarenko et al. [43]
1473K Feng et al. [44] DM ×
1473K and 1873K, liquidus projection Yaqoob et al. [3] EA, EPMA, XRD •
Thermodynamic properties Site occupancy of Yaqoob et al. [45] XRD •
Heat capacity of NMR-75 Chekhovskoi et al. [45] AC ×
TA: Thermal analysis; OM: optical metallography; XRD: X-ray diffraction; CA: chemical analysis; DTA: differential thermal analysis; DC:
diffusion couple; EPMA: electron probe microanalysis; EPS: electrolytic phase separation; EA: equilibrated alloys; DM: diffusion multiple;
AC: adiabatic calorimetry; EMF: electromotive force; FP: first-principles calculations; VSM: vibrating sample magnetometer; SQUID: su-
perconducting quantum interference device. aIndicates whether the data are used or not in the assessment: • used; ◦: used partially; ×:
not used.

to the experimental data for not only the binary but also the ternary system. One may argue the accuracy of
the experiments but it deserves a detailed study as discussed below. Moreover, when extrapolating the Mo-Re
system with the parameters of Mathieu et al. to the ternary system [53] , the Mo content in the bcc phase of
the three-phase equilibria (i.e., bcc + + Mo 3CoSi and bcc + Mo 3CoSi + ) was significantly higher than the
1
experimental data, which is caused by a large value of , used to fit the equilibria between the bcc and
phases.

Ni­Re
The experimental information of the Ni-Re binary system before 1985 has been reviewed critically by Nash et
al. and an assessed Ni-Re phase diagram was reported [54] . Later, Yaqoob and Joubert reinvestigated experi-
[6]
mentally and reassessed this binary system, and agreed well with most experimental data . Furthermore, the
invariant reaction temperature and corresponding compositions determined by Yaqoob and Joubert [6] were
reconfirmed by Boettinger et al. [55] . Thus, the thermodynamic parameters from Yaqoob and Joubert [6] were