Page 31 - Read Online
P. 31

Yoo et al. Hepatoma Res 2020;6:9  I  http://dx.doi.org/10.20517/2394-5079.2019.49                                                    Page 3 of 9  Table 1. Studies about de novo HCC occurrence after receiving DAAs in patients with hepatitis C virus infection





                                                                                                    Author
                     Ide et al. [25]
                                           Yoo et al. [22]
                                                                                                 Conti et al. [14]
                                   Singer et al. [23]
                           Carrat et al. [24]
                                                                Nahon et al. [21]
                                                                                             Kanwal et al. [17]
                                                                      Nagata et al. [20]
                                                                           Romano et al. [19]
                                                   Ioannou et al. [42]
                                                                                     Calvaruso et al. [18]
            CumI: cumulative incidence
                     Prospective
                                                                  cohort study
                                                                                               cohort study
                  cohort study
                                                              cohort study
                                         cohort study
                                               cohort study
                                 cohort study
                                                                          cohort study
                                                                                           cohort study
                                                                                   cohort study
                         cohort study
                    observational
                                                 observational
                                                                    observational
                                                   Retrospective
                                                                      Retrospective
                                                                                                    Study design
                           Prospective observational
                                                                Prospective observational
                                                                                     Prospective observational
                                                                           Prospective observational
                                           Retrospective observational
                                                                                             Retrospective observational
                                                                                                 Retrospective observational
                                   Retrospective observational
                    (n = 2552)
                                                                                           (n = 22,500)
                                       -IFN (n = 211)
                                                                    -IFN (n = 1145)
                                                                                               DAAs (n = 285)
                                                                  -DAAs (n = 752)
                                                                          DAAs (n = 3917)
                              -IFN (n =1 2,948)
                                         -DAAs (n = 574)
                                                                                   DAAs (n = 2249)
                                                            -DAAs (n = 336)
                         -DAA (n = 7344)
                                   Chronic hepatitis C
                                           Chronic hepatitis C
                                                                      Chronic hepatitis C
                                                   Chronic hepatitis C
                           Chronic hepatitis C
                                                         -non-SVR (n = 439)
                                                           -SVR-IFN (n = 495)
                                 -DAAs (n = 30,183)
                        -Untreated (n = 2551)
                                                                                                    Patient number
                               -Untreated (n = 137,502)
                                                 -IFN only (n = 35,871, 58%)
                                              -DAA only (n = 21,948, 35%)
                                                                           Fibrosis stage ≥ F3 CHC with
                                               -DAA + IFN (n = 4535, 7.2%)
                                                                                                 HCV-associated cirrhosis with
                                                                                     HCV-associated cirrhosis with
                                                                                             Chronic hepatitis C with DAAs
                     Chronic hepatitis C with DAAs
                                                              cirrhosis with DAAs (n = 1270)
                                                                Biopsy-proven HCV-associated
                                                                                     14
                               PY
                     NA
                                                                                                 5.6
                                                                                             NA
                                                                           17.9
                           33.4
                                                   73.2
                                                                67.5
                                                                      IFN 81.6
                                           IFN 43.6
                                                                    DAAs 21.6
                                         DAAs 10.4
                                                                                                   period (months)
                                                                                                     Median follow-up
                                   DAAs 1.05 PY
                                 Untreated 1.24
                     NA
                                                   NA
                                   NA
                                       IFN
                                      75.4%
                                         95.1%
                                           DAAs
                                                                                             86.74%
                                                                           93.90%
                                                                                                 91.00%
                                                                      96.00%
                                                                                     95.20%
                           94.00%
                                                                                                    SVR rate
                                                         3.1%
                                                     12.7%
                                                                          (1.4%)
                                                 (5.2%)
                    (2.7%)
                                                                                           (1.2%)
                                                                                               (3.16%)
                        (2.54%)
                                         (0.89%)
                                      - IFN (0.47%)
                                                                    viral eradication
                                       - DAAs (1.05%)
                                                              year-CumI 14.7%)
                                                                                                    Outcomes
                                                                                     HCC occurrence rate
                     HCC occurrence rate
                                   HCC occurrence rate
                                                   HCC occurrence rate
                                                                                             HCC occurrence rate
                                           HCC occurrence rate
                                                                                                 HCC occurrence rate
                                                                           HCC occurrence rate
                           HCC occurrence rate
                                 - DAAs 0.64/100 PY
                                                                                         - SVR (0.90/100 PY)
                         of DAA treated group
                                                                                - CPC B + SVR (7.8%)
                                                                                   - CPC A + SVR (2.1%)
                                                           - SVR-IFN 3-year CumI:
                               - Untreated 1.18/100 PY
                                                       - non-SVR 3-year CumI:
                                                                HCC occurrence rate (5
                                                                                        - non-SVR (3.45/100 PY)
                                                                                 - CPC A + no SVR (6.6%)
                                                                              - CPC B + no SVR (12.4%)
                                                                  - IFN (3.3%), DAAs (1.4%)
                                                                      HCC occurrence rate after
                                                            - DAAs 3-year CumI: 5.9%
                                                                  therapies
                                                              associated with DAA use
                                                                                               reduce occurrence of HCC
                                                                                   mean follow-up of 14 months
                                                                        lower, than that of untreated patients
                                               risk compared with treatment with IFN
                                                                                                    Conclusion
                               IFN-based treatment in the pre-DAA era
                                                                                           considerable reduction in the risk of HCC
                         risk for mortality and hepatocellular carcinoma
                                         patients treated with IFN and those treated with DAAs
                                                                    eradication were similar between IFN-based and IFN-free
                                                                                                 DAA-induced resolution of HCV infection does not seem to
                                                                      The risks of early HCC occurrence and recurrence after viral
                                   DAA-based treatment was associated with a reduced risk of
                                           The rate of early development of HCC did not differ between
                                                   DAA-induced SVR is associated with a 71% reduction in HCC
                                                                There is no statistically significant increase in risk of HCC was
                                 incident liver cancer relative to both no HCV treatment and to
                                                                          “de novo” HCC during the first year is not higher, and might be
                                                                                             Among patients treated with DAA, SVR was associated with a
                                                                                     SVR to DAA treatment decreased the incidence of HCC over a
                     Achieving SVR by DAA treatment reduces the incidence of HCC
                                                                           In patients with advanced hepatitis C receiving DAAs, the risk of
                                                 risk. Treatment with DAAs is not associated with increased HCC
                           Treatment with direct-acting antivirals is associated with reduced
              HCV: hepatitis C virus; DAAs: direct-acting antivirals; HCC: hepatocellular carcinoma; NA: not available; SVR: sustained virological response; PY: person-year; CPC: Child-Pugh Class; IFN: interferon;
   26   27   28   29   30   31   32   33   34   35   36